Behind the Scenes: The Surprising Original Title of HGTV’s Property Brothers

Since its debut in 2011, HGTV’s “Property Brothers,” starring twin siblings Drew and Jonathan Scott, has become a beloved fixture in home renovation television. The show’s immense popularity has led to multiple spin-offs, including “Celebrity IOU” and “Brother vs. Brother.” Interestingly, the title “Property Brothers” almost wasn’t their choice. The Scott brothers considered several alternative titles before finally embracing the one fans know today. If they had selected a different name, perhaps the show’s critics would have an even larger following!

Producers and the brothers brainstormed various possibilities such as “Bungalow Brothers,” “Builder Brothers,” “Brothers In Business,” and even “Bros Before Renos,” the latter of which was nearly the final choice, according to HGTV’s social media. However, the title “Property Brothers” did not immediately win everyone over; Drew was initially opposed to it. Jonathan recounted in an interview that Drew kept rejecting the suggestion, expressing concerns that the name was too general and that they could easily be replaced by other brothers who renovate homes. Jonathan had his own reservations too, wanting something that better showcased their distinct personalities. So, how did they come to select “Property Brothers” in the end?

Even though Drew and Jonathan Scott were initially uninterested in the title “Property Brothers,” it ultimately became the one that defined their series. Today, it’s difficult to envision the show achieving the same success with a different name, especially one like “Bros Before Renos,” which doesn’t quite fit their role as the actual renovators. The moniker “Property Brothers” captures their unique appeal—two actual brothers both dedicated to home improvement, with Drew focusing on real estate and Jonathan managing renovations.

Before entering the spotlight, the Scott brothers faced challenges in the acting world and even explored careers in music and magic. However, they quickly turned their focus to real estate, recognizing it as a dependable backup plan. Their successful foray into flipping houses showcased their growing expertise in home renovations, validating the suitability of the title “Property Brothers.” Drew’s earlier concerns about being replaceable faded as their bond and shared journey in this industry became evident, making it clear that no alternative title could have represented them better.