The Significance of Schumacher’s Cut of Batman Forever Today

Imagine being misjudged for about three decades, only for your most significant work to emerge posthumously. This is a common narrative in Hollywood.

On May 29, Los Angeles will feature a unique screening of the elusive Schumacher Cut of Batman Forever—a 2-hour-and-38-minute edit that strips away its campy elements to reveal Bruce Wayne’s deeper struggles. While it’s not set for a broad release yet, it represents hope. For those who have championed #ReleaseTheSchumacherCut, this could signal a breakthrough.

It’s important to note that this version isn’t quite ready for HBO Max. Estimates suggest it requires an additional $5M–$10M for finishing touches—like special effects, music, and clean-up. However, screenings earlier in 2023, including one led by Kevin Smith, garnered enthusiastic responses for its psychological complexity. According to screenwriter Akiva Goldsman, Schumacher’s original idea was “around 35% more psychologically realistic,” emphasizing themes of guilt and shame. Goldsman described it as “a cool film” that audiences weren’t prepared for back in 1995.

Perhaps, the time has come.

The harsh reality is that Schumacher has never truly been forgiven for Batman & Robin. That critique tainted Batman Forever, which was successful at the box office but received mixed reviews. Schumacher passed away in 2020, leaving behind a legacy marred by criticism over Bat-nipples and over-the-top aesthetics. This year, Val Kilmer, who portrayed a more subdued Bruce Wayne, also passed, making the timing especially poignant.

Historically, there’s an example here: Zack Snyder’s Justice League gained new life through fan advocacy and changing studio strategies. However, while Snyder had an active support base, Schumacher’s version has always been an underdog. This difference might not be about reclaiming commercial success but rather delivering posthumous recognition.

Additionally, consider that when Burton’s Batman Returns was released in ’92, it was criticized for being too dark. The studio reacted, bringing in Schumacher for a fresh take. Yet within the garish colors, there was a portrayal of Bruce Wayne’s psyche that audiences didn’t anticipate. Imagine a blend of Batman and A Beautiful Mind, albeit obscured by neon lights and rubber costumes.

The pressing issue now isn’t whether the Schumacher Cut exists—it certainly does. The real question is whether we find it valuable enough to support its completion. Are we willing to fund it? To honor Joel Schumacher in the way he deserved during his lifetime?

Would you contribute to a crowdfunding campaign for the cut? Share your thoughts below.